Blog

Sewer problems are something no home or property owner wants to deal with, but ignoring the warning signs can lead to property damage, health risks, and costly repairs. When you’re faced with recurring backups, foul smells, or slow drains, it may be time to make a critical decision:

Should you repair, reline, or replace your sewer line?

This blog walks you through what causes sewer line problems, when action is needed, and the key differences between sewer pipe repair vs relining vs replacement, with a closer look at why relining is often the smarter, faster, and more cost-effective option.

Comparison: Sewer Pipe Repair vs Relining vs Replacement

Common Sewer Line Problems That Trigger Repairs, Relining, and Replacements

Before diving into solutions, it helps to understand what typically causes sewer line issues. Here are the most common culprits:

1. Tree Root Intrusion

Tree roots are drawn to the moisture in sewer lines. Over time, they can infiltrate small cracks or joints in the pipe, causing blockages or breaks.

2. Pipe Corrosion or Deterioration

Older homes with cast iron, clay, or Orangeburg (bituminized fiber) pipes are especially prone to deterioration. These materials weaken with age, making them susceptible to cracks, leaks, and eventual collapse.

3. Recurring Clogs or Backups

If plunging and snaking aren’t solving the problem, the issue may lie deeper within your lateral sewer line — the pipe connecting your home to the main city sewer. And if you find yourself constantly calling out a plumber for the same problem, it may be time to seek further investigative services to identify the root cause.

4. Collapsed or Bellied Pipes

A section of the pipe may have sunk due to soil erosion, creating a “belly” that collects debris and blocks flow.

Sewer Pipe Repairs: Smaller Scale Remedies To Restore Functionality

Pros: 

• It may be more cost-effective than full replacement or relining.
• Prevents smaller issues from evolving into more complex and destructive problems.
• It can be customized to your precise specifications.
• Less time-consuming and labor-intensive than more comprehensive approaches.

Cons:

• It may not prevent the problem from recurring in the future.
• It can be disruptive if access points aren’t available.

Sewer Pipe Replacement: The Traditional (and Disruptive) Approach

Pros:

• New pipe material has a long lifespan (often 50–100 years).
• Useful if the existing pipe is completely collapsed or severely offset.

Cons:

• Requires digging up landscaping, driveways, sidewalks, or even floors.
• More expensive when factoring in the cost of property restoration.
• It may take several days, especially for deep or complex lines.
• Depending on your location, digging in public right-of-ways or other areas can complicate the job and require more permits.

Sewer pipe replacement is best when the line has completely failed or is crushed beyond repair, or when the pipe is visible and accessible above ground rather than buried.

Sewer Pipe Relining: A Modern, Trenchless Solution

Relining technology has revolutionized sewer pipe repairs. Rather than digging up the old pipe, contractors thoroughly clean the debris out and insert a resin-saturated liner. Once the liner is inflated, it cures in place, creating a durable, jointless new pipe within your old pipe.

Pros:

• No excavation needed — protects landscaping, driveways, patios, and more.
• Faster turnaround — most relining jobs are completed within one to two days.
• Durable solution — liners often come with 50-year warranties and resist root intrusion, corrosion, and leaks.
• Cost-effective — while the per-foot cost may seem higher than pipe material, it’s cheaper overall due to minimal excavation and restoration.
• Environmentally friendly — less heavy equipment, less fuel, and no soil or pipe disposal.

Cons:

• Slightly reduces the inner diameter of the pipe, but it does not impact normal household flow
• Not suitable for fully collapsed pipes.

Pipe Repair vs Relining vs Replacement: Why Sewer Pipe Relining is Often the Better Choice

For most residential sewer line issues, such as cracks, leaks, or root intrusion, sewer pipe relining is a cleaner, faster, and smarter fix.

1. Saves Your Landscaping and Hardscaping

Imagine replacing a sewer line that runs under your stamped concrete patio, mature trees, or flower beds. With relining, there’s no need to destroy what you’ve built; the work happens underground, through a single access point.

2. Minimizes Downtime

You don’t have to vacate your home for days. Most relining jobs are completed within 24 hours, and you can typically use your water again the same or the next day.

3. Avoids Hidden Restoration Costs

With traditional replacement, you’ll often face unexpected expenses for concrete work, landscaping, or interior flooring, none of which come cheaply. Relining avoids that domino effect.

4. Strong, Seamless Pipes That Resist Future Problems

CIPP liners are jointless, meaning tree roots, which typically enter at pipe seams, have no access. The resin creates a smooth interior surface that improves flow and resists buildup.

5. Eco-Friendly Repair Option

Fewer heavy machines, less soil disruption, and no disposal of old pipe material make relining a more sustainable choice for sewer pipe repair.

When Replacement Makes More Sense

While relining is ideal for most scenarios, there are a few situations where replacement is still the better option:

• The pipe has completely collapsed, blocking any chance of inserting a liner.
• The line has severe joint misalignments or sags that can’t be corrected with relining.
• You’re upgrading to a larger pipe diameter (e.g., for a new addition or expanded plumbing system).

A professional sewer pipe camera inspection will determine whether relining is a viable option.

Pipe Repair vs Relining vs Replacement: Choose the Right Fix, Not Just the Traditional One

Sewer pipe problems are stressful, but your repair process doesn’t have to be. Sewer pipe relining offers a modern alternative to disruptive trench digging — one that’s faster, cleaner, and often more cost-effective.

If you’ve been told your only option is excavation, get a second opinion. A reputable plumbing or trenchless specialist can inspect your line and explain whether relining is the smarter long-term solution for your property.

In many cases, you don’t need to dig up your yard, you just need the right team and the right technology.

Need help deciding between sewer line repairs, relining, and replacement? Reach out to one of our licensed trenchless repair experts in your area. We’ll start with a thorough camera inspection and estimate, then we’ll work on a solution that fits your needs, so you don’t have to guess the winner when it comes to pipe repair vs relining vs replacement.

GET A QUOTE